Nestled amidst the shimmering waters of the pristine Butler Chain of Lakes, Windermere, Florida, particularly the highly coveted 34786 zip code, stands as a beacon of luxury, tranquility, and unparalleled quality of life in Central Florida.
Known affectionately as the "Town Among the Lakes," this exclusive community offers a unique blend of natural beauty, sophisticated residences, and convenient access to world-class amenities and attractions. For those aspiring to an elevated lifestyle, Windermere Florida homes for sale 34786 represent not just a property purchase, but an investment in an exceptional living experience within one of the most desirable and prestigious real estate markets in the Sunshine State.
The 34786 zip code encompasses the very heart of Windermere, a town that has diligently preserved its historic charm with unpaved, tree-lined streets, a testament to its commitment to maintaining a serene and distinctive character. This dedication to natural beauty and a peaceful atmosphere is a primary magnet for discerning homebuyers, particularly those seeking a respite from the hustle and bustle without sacrificing convenience.
The Windermere real estate market 34786 is robust, characterized by high property values and sustained demand for luxury homes.As of mid-2025, the market shows signs of stabilization after rapid appreciation, with a blend of resilience and moderation.While sales volume has seen a slight decline year-over-year, median home prices have continued their upward trajectory, reflecting the area's enduring appeal.
Median Home Sale Price: Approximately $1.8 million (May 2025, for all home sizes), with the median list price around $1,095,500. This variance often reflects the significant portion of high-end, luxury, and estate properties sold in the area.
Inventory Levels: Active listings remain constrained, hovering around 150 properties as of May 2025, a 10% decrease from the previous year. This limited supply contributes to upward price pressure, particularly for premium properties.
Days on Market: Homes typically spend around 34 days on the market, indicating a relatively swift transaction period, especially for well-appointed listings.
Mortgage Rates: Stabilized around 6.25% for a 30-year fixed loan, remaining relatively affordable for high-end buyers.
Buyer/Seller Dynamics: While the market retains a slight seller's edge, there's a cooling trend.
Around 65-70% of homes sold below asking price in early 2025, offering buyers more negotiation leverage, especially for mid-tier properties.
This data underscores Windermere's status as a highly competitive market, particularly for luxury and estate properties, where demand consistently outpaces supply.
The homes for sale in Windermere FL 34786 cater to a broad spectrum of preferences, although luxury properties form the bedrock of the market. From expansive lakeside estates to elegant single-family homes and select charming townhomes, there’s a property to fulfill various desires and needs.
Luxury homes in Windermere FL 34786 define the architectural and lifestyle landscape. These grand properties frequently showcase:
Architectural Grandeur: Predominantly Mediterranean, but also contemporary, traditional, and modern farmhouses, often with sophisticated finishes and custom designs.
Expansive Interiors: Ranging from 4-5 bedrooms in spacious single-family homes to 8-10+ bedrooms in larger estates, featuring open floor plans, soaring ceilings, and abundant natural light.
Premium Features and Finishes:
Gourmet kitchens equipped with professional-grade appliances, quartz or granite countertops, custom cabinetry, smart home technology, walk-in closets, and often luxurious additions like home theaters, fitness rooms, climate-controlled wine cellars, and humidors.
Elaborate Outdoor Living Spaces: Designed for entertainment and relaxation, these homes often include resort-style pools with spas, outdoor kitchens, fireplaces, meticulously landscaped gardens, and private lakeside docks.
Given its unparalleled location on the Butler Chain of Lakes waterfront homes in Windermere FL 34786 are among the most sought-after properties.These residences offer direct access to interconnected lakes, providing endless opportunities for boating, fishing, paddleboarding, and waterskiing.Imagine waking up to serene lake views and having your private dock just steps from your back door. These homes truly embody the pinnacle of luxury living in Windermere.
For those desiring contemporary designs, energy efficiency, and the latest in home technology, new construction homes in Windermere FL 34786 are increasingly available. Reputable builders like Dream Finders Homes and Toll Brothers are actively developing new communities and custom homes, offering state-of-the-art features, open-concept layouts, and the opportunity for personalized finishes. These homes reflect modern aesthetics and cater to a low-maintenance, sophisticated lifestyle.Communities such as Palms at Windermere and Saddlecrest at Windermere are examples of current or upcoming new construction options.
A defining characteristic of the Windermere real estate market is its array of gated communities in Windermere FL 34786.
These enclaves offer residents enhanced security, privacy, and often exclusive access to a wealth of luxury amenities.
Some of the most prestigious include:
Isleworth:
World-renowned for its opulent estates, championship golf course, and high-profile residents.
Keene's Pointe:
Featuring a Jack Nicklaus-designed golf course, this community is celebrated for its beautiful homes and family-friendly atmosphere.
Lake Butler Sound:
An exclusive community with stunning estate homes and private lake access, often comparable to Isleworth in price and prestige.
Waterstone on Lake Butler:
A prominent gated community known for its custom-built homes and direct access to Lake Butler.
Bellaria / Casabella:
Luxurious enclaves with modern mansions, offering high-end living.
Oxford Moor:
An established and respected gated community in West Windermere, featuring luxury homes and a central lake.
Sawyer Sound:
A smaller, exclusive gated community with custom-built homes near Lake Sawyer.
Tilden's Grove: Known for its high-quality homes and a strong sense of community within a secure setting.
Living in Windermere, FL 34786, means embracing a lifestyle that seamlessly blends upscale living with abundant natural beauty and convenient access to Central Florida’s most celebrated attractions.
The Butler Chain of Lakes is undeniably the jewel of Windermere's outdoor recreational offerings.
Residents regularly enjoy:
Boating and Water Sports: The interconnected lakes provide a perfect playground for kayaking, paddleboarding, waterskiing, wakeboarding, and bass fishing.
Parks and Nature Preserves:
Windermere is home to numerous community parks, offering lush green spaces, playgrounds, sports courts, and scenic walking trails.The Tibet Butler Nature Preserve, with its extensive trails through diverse ecosystems, is a haven for nature lovers and birdwatchers.
Championship Golfing:
Golf enthusiasts will revel in the proximity to world-class golf courses, including the Golden Bear Club at Keene's Pointe and the renowned Arnold Palmer's Bay Hill Club & Lodge.
Upscale Shopping, Diverse Dining, and Entertainment
While Windermere maintains its charming, historic small-town feel with local boutiques and cafes in Downtown Windermere, residents benefit from easy access to an array of major retail and dining establishments just minutes away.
Downtown Windermere:
Explore unique local shops, enjoy coffee at spots like Paloma Coffee Co., and experience the vibrant weekly Windermere Farmer's Market.
The Grove: This upscale outdoor shopping center, a short drive away, provides essential services, grocery stores, and a variety of casual and fine dining options.
Proximity to Orlando:
Windermere's strategic location offers unparalleled access to Orlando's vast array of shopping malls, diverse culinary scene, vibrant cultural institutions (such as the Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts, Orlando Philharmonic, and Orlando Ballet), and, of course, the world-famous theme parks including Walt Disney World Resort and Universal Studios Florida.
For families considering Windermere FL homes for sale 34786, the exceptional educational opportunities are a significant draw.
The area is served by highly-rated public schools within the Orange County Public School district, known for their strong academic programs and extracurricular activities:
Elementary Schools: Bay Lake Elementary, Keenes Crossing Elementary, Sunset Park Elementary, Windermere Elementary.
Middle Schools:Gotha Middle School, Horizon West Middle School.
High Schools: Windermere High School (ranked among the best public high schools in Florida).
Additionally, prestigious private institutions such as Windermere Preparatory School offer outstanding educational alternatives, providing a comprehensive range of academic and athletic programs.
The cost of living in Windermere, FL, is higher than the national average, primarily driven by its premium housing market.
However, Florida’s lack of state income tax can provide some financial offsets.
Population (2025 Estimate): Approximately 3,132, with a steady annual growth rate of 0.64%, reflecting controlled, thoughtful development.
Median Household Income:
Roughly $156,042, indicating a prosperous community.
Homeownership Rate: A high 94.7%, underscoring the stability and investment appeal of the area.
Demographics: Predominantly White (Non-Hispanic) at around 79.1%, with a diverse mix of other ethnic groups.
Property Taxes: Orange County property taxes are due by March 31st each year. Early payment discounts are available (e.g., 4% in November, 3% in December). The median effective property tax rate in Orange County is around 1.16%, which is slightly higher than the national median. For Windermere specifically, the median tax rate is approximately 1.24%.
HOA Fees: Homeowners Association (HOA) fees vary significantly based on the community and its amenities. In some communities like The Lakes of Windermere, quarterly dues can be around $225-$240, while exclusive gated communities with extensive amenities like golf courses and security will command significantly higher monthly or annual fees. These fees cover community maintenance, common areas, and often a range of luxury services.
Rental Market: While primarily an ownership market, single-family home rentals average around $3,150 per month (mid-2025), reflecting the premium on living in this desirable area.
Windermere, FL 34786, offers more than just a place to live; it provides a comprehensive lifestyle of sophistication, comfort, and natural beauty.
It's a community where luxury is seamlessly integrated with tranquility, where natural landscapes are meticulously preserved, and where world-class amenities are always within reach.
Choose Windermere 34786 if you seek:
Exquisite Lakeside Living: Direct access to the Chain of Lakes for unparalleled water sports and serene waterfront enjoyment.
Prestigious Communities:
Secure, gated neighborhoods offering the utmost in privacy, security, and a wealth of luxury facilities.
Exceptional Education:
Access to top-rated public and private schools, ensuring excellent educational opportunities for families.
Strategic Location:
Enjoy the peaceful residential atmosphere while being just minutes away from Orlando's vibrant city life, world-famous theme parks, diverse dining, and premier shopping destinations.
Strong Community Spirit:
A vibrant and welcoming community with local events, farmer's markets, and a palpable sense of belonging.
Investment Value:
A resilient real estate market with sustained demand and appreciating property values, making it a sound long-term investment.
The Windermere Florida real estate market 34786 is an invitation to invest in a lifestyle that epitomizes elegance and convenience.
Whether your dream is a sprawling waterfront estate, a sleek new construction, or a spacious family home within a secure community, Windermere 34786 offers exceptional options for the most discerning buyers.
Navigating the competitive and high-value Windermere FL real estate market, particularly within the exclusive 34786 zip code, requires expert guidance and profound local insight. Partnering with a highly knowledgeable and experienced Windermere FL real estate agent 34786 is paramount to a successful home search and purchase. A dedicated local agent can provide:
In-depth Market Insights: Access to the latest listings, real-time market trends, and accurate property valuations, including off-market opportunities.
Unparalleled Neighborhood Expertise: Comprehensive knowledge of the unique characteristics, amenities, and lifestyle offerings of each prestigious community within the 34786 zip code.
Access to Exclusive Listings: Often, the most desirable and high-value properties are discovered through an agent's extensive network before they even hit the broader market.
Skilled Negotiation: Expert representation and negotiation strategies to ensure you secure the best possible terms and price for your chosen property.
Seamless Transaction Management: Guidance through every step of the buying process, from initial search to closing, making the experience smooth and stress-free.
Begin your journey to finding your extraordinary Windermere Florida homes for sale 34786 today. Let a local expert unlock the door to your dream lakeside lifestyle in this magnificent Central Florida gem. Your perfect home awaits.
407-575-5392
Wendy Morris LLC
Licensed in the State of Florida
BK 3146762
16797 Broadwater Avenue
Winter Garden, Florida 34787
